WHEN REVISION BECOMES NECESSARY

REVISIONS IN THE FAMILY TREE

.

Genealogical Research can result in needing to revise a family tree. It is important to go back to actual historical records if you can find them, to be sure. My goal is to offer information that is as accurate as possible.

.

My other major goal for this blog is to make the wealth of information that I have, including family stories and accounts, to be accessible to other family branches. It is a heritage held in common, and should be shared. This blog is the easiest means for me to make this material public. I do wish to be credited for my work, my time, for technical expertise in photo-enhancement and for my writing. Posting on this blog is a statement of copyright.

.

Revision is not easily achieved in a blog post. I will revise the Pages containing the Family Tree, (which is easier in Pages than changing Posts.) Eventually I will replace parts of Family Biographies if revision is needed, and delete the earlier version. This means the order of posts will not correspond to the sequential order of the Biographies, and the information must be sequenced by date by the reader. To make the updates available, I will also organize posts pertaining to changes in information under the Label, “Revisions.”

.

I would appreciate input from other relatives who may refer to this site about the need for revisions, and will credit that person with their contribution, and name resources for information as well.

.

Why Are Personal Records Wrong?

.

They aren't always wrong, but people writing family trees and writing obituaries frequently make mistakes, misremember, may purposely omit information, and sometimes purposely misrepresent certain details. Unfortunately, close relatives may even secede from your branch if you revise the party line in favor of documented truth.

.

This gets worse when a person disagrees with the experiences of different members and their personal stories. Often in a family gathering two people present may have different experiences at the time, and their recollections will also differ. Sometimes the person himself or herself doesn’t want a particular fact of their own life to be told, and has a vested interest in keeping secrets.

.

In the Valencourt branch of my family, a great grandmother Virginia is named differently in some other parallel family lineages. But because that grandmother lived with her son Charles in Oregon, and died in his care, I believe my mother’s records are probably correct. Until I find historic documents, such as a census, birth records, marriage records, death records and other documents, that indicate differently, I will assume the version here is accurate.

.

In the Bowers Lineage there are discrepancies.

A friend of mine, Kristina Bain, explained that “before the 1850 census, the households just listed the male head (without a birth date) and put everyone else in numerical categories (i.e. 1 male age 50-60, 1 female aged 50—60, two females age 30-40 etc…) so sorting out, the Joab Bowers family may require further inquiries at the genealogical /historical societies in the places they lived & died for wills, property records etc.”

My friend said the Babcock Lineage conformed with another source, and is probably trustworthy material.

.

The Starr Lineage: I was quite amazed to hear that there may be two more unrecorded generations in the Starr Lineage, and that some of the recorded names may be different than originally thought. I have included that part of the Starr Lineage where changes may be indicated, and need more research. See bold black entries below, which suggest changes are needed.

.

MATERNAL FAMILY TREE - STARR LINEAGE

1 Dr. Comfort Starr came to this country on the Mayflower from Ashire England in 1620.

2 Thomas Starr. was put in prison for being sympathetic with the Indians.

He was later released and given a tract of land in Connecticut as compensation. He raised his family in Thompsonville, CN.

3. Elias Starr (The One World Tree on Ancestry.com names this ancestor as Josiah)

(The One World Tree on Ancestry.com names two more generations, Benjamin Starr and another David Starr)

.

4. David Starr

.

5. Johnathon Starr was married to Sally. The couple had three children, Sara and William J. (third unknown.) (The One World Tree on Ancestry.com names this ancestor as Elnathan)

.

6 William J Starr, was born Nov. 8, 1843.He died Mar. 19, 1907.

He married Eliza Jane Reynolds (Dutch) in Fallsburg NY. She was born Jan 20, 18-- and died Oct. 7, 1886. Her parents were Andrew Reynolds and Catherine Vanbenscoten (Dutch)

They were one of the first Free Methodist families in the country.

They had 13 children in all, in New York State, including Martha Starr Strong, Sarah Starr Paul, Emma Starr Van Inwegen, Margaret Starr Main, George Starr, Willard Starr, Laura Starr Bowers, Andrew Starr, Flora Starr Wheat, Louella Starr Case, Ava Starr Frazier, Herman Starr, and Arthur Starr.

Two additional sisters are also named in the One World Tree on Ancestrry.com. but I suspect these may be cases where a second name was used, or they died as babies, as my great grandmother Laura personally told me there were thirteen children in all, and she had twelve brothers and sisters. Also I believe her middle name was Jane, but have no documentation.(I was about eleven. Ruth Zachary.)

.

Writing and layout of Biographical Pages are the © Copyright of Ruth Zachary.